photo credit: Anant N S ( via photopin cc

How I Handle Anti-SDA Assaults

photo credit: Anant N S ( via photopincc

I get emails and comments every month that range from friendly to hostile. Adventists often write and thank me for this blog. Members of other denominations write and engage me in friendly debates. And of course, others (sometimes former Adventists sometimes not) write with aggressive tones, angry accusations, and hostile inquiries. I have had people email me to tell me ever so kindly that I am in a cult, that the church I love teaches heresy, that Ellen White was a false prophet, and that the SDA church has roots in freemasonry. I have had people tell me that the teachings of our church are unbiblical and built upon "the leaven of Ellen White," that I am in a "works-based religion," and countless other statements that I cannot even remember.

So how do I respond? With grace. At times this has helped turn the attacker into a friend, but there are other instances in which no amount of kindness has helped. Some people write with one goal in mind: to argue with me. They are not interested in common ground. They are not interested in appreciating my faith and having a respectful conversation. They just want to fight. But I made up my mind a long time ago that fighting about religion is immature and downright ridiculous. What's funny is when I refuse to argue but instead open an invitation to respectful and friendly dialogue these would be defenders of the truth never write back. I am left wondering, if I really was in a cult how in the world do these people expect to help me by bombarding me with hostile accusations from every possible angle? To those who like to attack my church, allow me to share with you a response I gave to one of my many assailants: "Is it possible that I am misled? Of course! But if you know the truth, you certainly are not doing a great job of wooing me toward it."

I am not surprised when people are hostile toward the SDA church. First of all, the SDA church is still relatively new in the world of Protestantism. Study the history of protestant denominations and you will see that every time a new denomination popped up the old ones were hostile toward them. As a matter of fact, SDA's are lucky when we are called a cult. Historically speaking many members of new protestant denominations were fatally persecuted by members of the older protestant denominations. "Because of the belief of opposing infant baptism and refusing to fight in wars, Anabaptists were persecuted by Catholics, Lutherans, Anglicans, and Calvinists. Hundreds to thousands of them were tortured and executed for their beliefs."* This trend continued as late as the arrival of the Methodists and Seventh Day Baptists. John Wesley encountered fierce persecution during his life, even to the point of being dragged out of his home by an angry mob that wanted to kill him. John James, a Seventh Day Baptist preacher, was martyred in 1661 for his political views. So when people call the SDA church a cult, as much as it hurts, I am thankful. I bet John James would have preferred such treatment.

At the end of the day the aggressors will always be there. There is nothing I can do about that, but as we begin this new year I would like to thank everyone who has ever dialogued with me in this blog and has done so with kindness and respect. Even when we disagree entirely it is always refreshing to talk about our differences with love. If that is you, don't stop writing me. I love to hear from you even if our faiths are polar opposites.

Wishing you all a happy new year.




  1. In reading your responses to those that disagree with you I have observed the very graceful treatment that you advocate in this post. Thanks.

  2. Unfortionatly Marcus not everyone will except the truth no matter what. They didn't when Christ was here on earth and they don't today. What seems so plain and correct to us is completely foreign to them because of what they have been taught and have accepted as truth. All of the SDA beliefs can be backed up with scripture but that doesn't seem to matter. Christ came to spread the truth and was rejected so we shouldn't feel bad when we are. Christ says love your neighbor and your enemy and by doing so more will be brought into the truth by our testimony.

    1. Interesting that you didn't mention the gospel in your list of SDA things that you are thankful for. Just sayin...

    2. What exactly are you referring to?

  3. I agree with the first comment. You have ALWAYS been a man of grace in your responses to those who may disagree with the SDA church. (Teresa)

  4. I am so glad to find your web page again. Its comforting to see how you handle people. I have come accross so many attacks on the SDA church...they have web pages especially dedicated to warn everyone that sda is a cult and ex sda making fun of thier childhood memories and so thankful they have gotten out....sda is portrayed as a very evil cult religion...I have been bombarded in a restaurant just because my food / drink order was different....or I go to church on a different day (all otheres are the same except you} can be discouraging but I think I am very thankful I am sda...I am thankful for the health message, the sabbath and many more even if I know sda people are not perfect just like all others...regardless I will stay in...I havent seen anything wrong with Ellen G White...she is a good woman...I dont see anything wrong with being I agree with comment number 1 and 2:-)


Please feel free to share your thoughts! Just remember to keep your comments friendly and relevant. Comments that are not risk being incinerated in cyber space. Happy typing! :D